If you are like many of your peers you are looking to Google Cloud to reduce overheads, drive innovation, and agility with a wide variety of databases for your Oracle workloads. From Bare Metal Solution to cloud-native databases, Google Cloud offers the infrastructure to meet your needs.

The Benefits

Optimizing your Oracle workloads with Google Cloud solutions has a number of benefits.

Dramatically reduce TCO: Reduce up-front hardware, software, and maintenance costs. Migrating Oracle workloads to Google Cloud could result in up to 78% in TCO savings.

High scale and high availability: Mission-critical applications need dependable databases that scale with your business. Google Cloud offers SLA-backed databases to protect your apps.

Simplify operation: Reduce data center and database management by leveraging managed infrastructure and fully managed database services.

Migration Strategies

Google Cloud provides multiple strategies for your specific migration journey to help you with licensing, maintenance cost, and manageability.

Rehost: To migrate Oracle workloads with specific configurations, Google Cloud offers Bare Metal Solution, where you can simply lift and shift your workloads. Bare Metal Solution provides hardware, hardware support, and integrated billing and support. This infrastructure is connected with a highly resilient interconnect and connects to all native Google Cloud services with less than 2ms latency.

Replatform: Keep your core application code and migrate to compatible platforms to help reduce licensing fees and maintenance costs. You can migrate to an open source database such as Cloud SQL for PostgreSQL that has a certain amount of compatibility with PL/SQL and stored procedure. You can also offload data analytics-centric workloads to SQL-compatible data warehousing solutions like BigQuery.

Rewrite: Rewrite your application to take full advantage of cloud-native databases. If your application requires a relational database with global scalability, you can migrate to Cloud Spanner, which provides scalability with industry-leading high availability of 99.999% SLA.

Want to know the latest from Google Cloud? Find it here in one handy location. Check back regularly for our newest updates, announcements, resources, events, learning opportunities, and more. 

Tip: Not sure where to find what you’re looking for on the Google Cloud blog? Start here: Google Cloud blog 101: Full list of topics, links, and resources.

Week of May 24-May 28 2021

• Google Cloud for financial services: driving your transformation cloud journey–As we welcome the industry to our Financial Services Summit, we’re sharing more on how Google Cloud accelerates a financial organization’s digital transformation through app and infrastructure modernization, data democratization, people connections, and trusted transactions. Read more or watch the summit on demand.
• Introducing Datashare solution for financial services–We announced the general availability of Datashare for financial services, a new Google Cloud solution that brings together the entire capital markets ecosystem—data publishers and data consumers—to exchange market data securely and easily. Read more.
• Announcing Datastream in Preview–Datastream, a serverless change data capture (CDC) and replication service, allows enterprises to synchronize data across heterogeneous databases, storage systems, and applications reliably and with minimal latency to support real-time analytics, database replication, and event-driven architectures. Read more.
• Introducing Dataplex: An intelligent data fabric for analytics at scale–Dataplex provides a way to centrally manage, monitor, and govern your data across data lakes, data warehouses and data marts, and make this data securely accessible to a variety of analytics and data science tools. Read more. 
• Announcing Dataflow Prime–Available in Preview in Q3 2021, Dataflow Prime is a new platform based on a serverless, no-ops, auto-tuning architecture built to bring unparalleled resource utilization and radical operational simplicity to big data processing. Dataflow Prime builds on Dataflow and brings new user benefits with innovations in resource utilization and distributed diagnostics. The new capabilities in Dataflow significantly reduce the time spent on infrastructure sizing and tuning tasks, as well as time spent diagnosing data freshness problems. Read more.
• Secure and scalable sharing for data and analytics with Analytics Hub–With Analytics Hub, available in Preview in Q3, organizations get a rich data ecosystem by publishing and subscribing to analytics-ready datasets; control and monitoring over how their data is being used; a self-service way to access valuable and trusted data assets; and an easy way to monetize their data assets without the overhead of building and managing the infrastructure. Read more.
• Cloud Spanner trims entry cost by 90%–Coming soon to Preview, granular instance sizing in Spanner lets organizations run workloads at as low as 1/10th the cost of regular instances, equating to approximately $65/month. Read more.
• Cloud Bigtable lifts SLA and adds new security features for regulated industries–Bigtable instances with a multi-cluster routing policy across 3 or more regions are now covered by a 99.999% monthly uptime percentage under the new SLA. In addition, new Data Access audit logs can help determine whether sensitive customer information has been accessed in the event of a security incident, and if so, when, and by whom. Read more.
• Build a no-code journaling app–In honor of Mental Health Awareness Month, Google Cloud’s no-code application development platform, AppSheet, demonstrates how you can build a journaling app complete with titles, time stamps, mood entries, and more. Learn how with this blog and video here.
• New features in Security Command Center—On May 24th, Security Command Center Premium launched the general availability of granular access controls at project- and folder-level and Center for Internet Security (CIS) 1.1 benchmarks for Google Cloud Platform Foundation. These new capabilities enable organizations to improve their security posture and efficiently manage risk for their Google Cloud environment. Learn more.
• Simplified API operations with AI–Google Cloud’s API management platform Apigee applies Google’s industry leading ML and AI to your API metadata. Understand how it works with anomaly detection here.
• This week: Data Cloud and Financial Services Summits–Our Google Cloud Summit series begins this week with the Data Cloud Summit on Wednesday May 26 (Global). At this half-day event, you’ll learn how leading companies like PayPal, Workday, Equifax, and many others are driving competitive differentiation using Google Cloud technologies to build their data clouds and transform data into value that drives innovation. The following day, Thursday May 27 (Global & EMEA) at the Financial Services Summit, discover how Google Cloud is helping financial institutions such as PayPal, Global Payments, HSBC, Credit Suisse, AXA Switzerland and more unlock new possibilities and accelerate business through innovation. Read more and explore the entire summit series.
• Announcing the Google for Games Developer Summit 2021 on July 12th-13th–With a surge of new gamers and an increase in time spent playing games in the last year, it’s more important than ever for game developers to delight and engage players. To help developers with this opportunity, the games teams at Google are back to announce the return of the Google for Games Developer Summit 2021 on July 12th-13th. Hear from experts across Google about new game solutions they’re building to make it easier for you to continue creating great games, connecting with players and scaling your business. Registration is free and open to all game developers. Register for the free online event at g.co/gamedevsummit to get more details in the coming weeks. We can’t wait to share our latest innovations with the developer community. Learn more.

Abstract

In this blog, we describe our journey to the cloud and share some lessons we learned along the way. Our hope is that you’ll find this information helpful as you go through the decision, execution, and completion of your own migration to the cloud.

Introduction

LiveRamp is a data enablement platform powered by identity, centered on privacy, integrated everywhere. Everything we do centers on making data safe and easy for businesses to use. Our Safe Haven platform powers customer intelligence, engages customers at scale, and creates breakthrough opportunities for business growth.

Businesses safely and securely bring us their data for enrichment and use the insights gained to deliver better customer experiences and generate more valuable business outcomes. Our fully interoperable and neutral infrastructure delivers end-to-end addressability for the world’s top brands, agencies, and publishers. Our platforms are designed to handle the variability and surge of the workload and guarantee service-level agreements (SLAs) to businesses.

We process petabytes of batch and streaming data daily. We ingest, process (join and enhance), and distribute this data. We receive and distribute data from thousands of partners and customers on a daily basis. We maintain the world’s largest and most accurate identity graph and work with more than 50 leading demand-side and supply-side platforms.

Our decision to migrate to Google Cloud and Dataproc

As an early adopter of Apache Hadoop, we had a single on-prem production managed Hadoop cluster that was used to store all of LiveRamp’s persistent data (HDFS) and run the Hadoop jobs that make up our data pipeline (YARN). The cluster consisted of around 2500 physical machines with a total of 30PB or raw storage, ~90,000 vcores, and ~300TB of memory. Engineering teams managed and ran multiple MapReduce jobs on these clusters.

The sheer volume of applications that LiveRamp ran on this cluster caused frequent resource contention issues, not to mention potentially widespread outages if an application was tuned improperly. Our business was scaling and we were running into constraints related to data center space and power in our on-premises environment. These constraints restricted our ability to meet our business objectives so a strategic decision was made to leverage elastic environments and migrate to the cloud. The decision required financial analysis and a detailed understanding of the available options, from do-it-yourself and vendor-managed distributions to leveraging cloud-managed services.

LiveRamp’s target architecture

We ultimately chose Google Cloud and Dataproc, a managed service for Hadoop, Spark, and other big data frameworks. During the migration we made a few fundamental changes to our Hadoop infrastructure:

Instead of 1 large persistent cluster managed by a central team, we have decentralized the cluster ownership to individual teams. This gave the teams flexibility to recreate, perform upgrades or change configurations as they see fit. This also gives us better cost attribution, less blast radius for errors, and less chance that – a rogue job from one team will impact the rest of the workloads.

Persistent data is no longer stored in HDFS on the clusters, it is in Google Cloud Storage, which, conveniently, served as a drop in replacement, as GCS is compatible with all the same APIs as HDFS. This means we can delete all the virtual machines that are part of the cluster without losing any data.

Introduced autoscaling clusters to control compute cost, and to dramatically decrease request latency. On premise you’re paying for the machines so you might as well use them. Cloud compute is elastic so you want to burst when there is demand and scale down when you can.

For example, one of our teams runs about 100,000 daily Spark jobs on 12 Dataproc clusters that each independently scale up to 1000 VMs. This gives that team a current peak capacity of about 256,000 cores. Because the team is bound to its own GCP Project inside of a GCP Organization, the cost attributed to that team is now very easy to report. The team uses architecture represented below to distribute the jobs across the clusters. This architecture allows them to bin similar workloads together so that they can be optimized together. Below is the logical architecture of the above workload:

Our approach

Overall migration and post migration stabilization/optimization of the largest of our workloads took us about several years to complete. We broadly broke down the migration into multiple phases.

Initial Proof-Of-Concept

When analyzing solutions for cloud-hosted big data services, any product had to meet our clear acceptance criteria:

1. Cost: Dataproc is not particularly expensive compared to similar alternatives, but our discount with the existing managed Hadoop partner made it expensive. We have initially accepted that the cost would remain the same. We did see cost benefits post migration, after several rounds of optimizations.
2. Features: Some key features (compared to current state) that we were looking for are built-in autoscaler, ease of creating/updating/deleting clusters, managed big data technologies etc.
3. Integration with GCP: As we had already decided to move other LiveRamp-owned services to GCP, a big data platform with robust integration with GCP was a must. Basically, we’d like to be able to leverage GCP features without a lot of effort on our end (custom vms, preemptible vms, etc).
4. Performance: Cluster creation, deletion, scale up, and scale down should be fast. This will allow teams to iterate and react quickly. These are some rough estimates of how fast the cluster operations should be:

• Cluster creation: <15 minutes
• Cluster Deletion: <15 minutes
• Adding 50 nodes: <20 minutes
• Removing 200 nodes: <10 minutes

5. Reliability: Bug free and low downtime software that has concrete SLAs on clusters and a strong commitment to the correct functioning of all of its features.

An initial prototype to better understand Dataproc and Google Cloud helped us prove that target technologies and architecture will give us reliability and cost improvements. This also fed into our decisions around target architecture. This was then reviewed by the Google team before we embarked on the migration journey.

Overall migration

Terraform module

Our ultimate goal is to create self-service tooling that allows our data engineers to deploy infrastructure as easily and safely as possible. After defining some best practices around cluster creation and configuration, the central team’s first step was to build a terraform module that can be used by all the teams to create their own clusters. This module will create a dataproc cluster along with all supporting buckets, pods and datadog monitors:

• A dataproc cluster autoscaling policy that can be customized
• A dataproc cluster with LiveRamp defaults preconfigured
• Sidecar applications for recording job metrics from the job history server and for monitoring the cluster health
• Pre configured datadog cluster health monitors for alerting

This Terraform module is also composed of multiple supporting modules underneath. This allows users to call the supporting modules directly in your project terraform as well if such a need arises. The module can be used to create a cluster by just setting the parameters like project id, path to application source (Spark or Map/Reduce), subnet, VM instance type, auto scaling policy etc.

Workload migration

Based on our analysis of Dataproc, discussions with GCP team and the POC, we used following criteria:

• We prioritized applications that can use preemptibles to achieve cost parity to our existing workloads
• We prioritized some of our smaller workloads initially to build momentum within the organization. For example, we left the single workload that accounted for ~40% of our overall batch volume to the end, after we had gained enough experience as an organization.
• We combined the migration to Spark along with the migration to Dataproc. This has initially resulted in some extra dev work but helped reduce the effort for testing and other activities.

Our initial approach was to lift and shift from existing managed providers and Map/Reduce to Dataproc and Spark. We then later focused on optimizing the workloads for cost and reliability.

What’s working well

Cost Attribution

As is true with any business, it’s important to know where your cost centers are. Moving from a single cluster, made opaque by the number of teams loading work onto it, to GCP’s Organization/Project structure has made cost reporting very simple. The tool breaks down cost by project, but also allows us to attribute cost to a single cluster via tagging. As we sometimes deploy a single application to a cluster, this helps us to make strategic decisions on cost optimizations at an application level very easily.

Flexibility

The programmatic nature of deploying Hadoop clusters in a cloud like GCP dramatically reduces the time and effort involved in making infrastructure changes. LiveRamp’s use of a self-service Terraform module means that a data engineering team can very quickly iterate on cluster configurations. This allows a team to create a cluster that is best for their application while also adhering to our security and health monitoring standards. We also get all the benefits of infrastructure as code: highly complicated infrastructure state is version controlled and can be easily recreated and modified in a safe way.

Support

When our teams face issues with services that run on Dataproc, the GCP team is always quick to respond. They work very closely with LiveRamp to develop new features for our needs. They proactively provide LiveRamp with preview access to new features that help LiveRamp to stay ahead of the curve in the Data Industry.

Cost Savings

We have achieved around 30% cost savings in certain clusters by achieving the right balance between on-demand and PVMs. The cost savings were a result of our engineers building efficient A/B testing frameworks that helped us run the clusters/jobs in several configurations to arrive at the most reliable, maintainable and cost efficient configuration. Also, one of the applications is now 10x + faster.

Five lessons learned

Migration was a successful exercise that took about six months to complete, across all our teams and applications. While many aspects went really well, we also learned a few things along the way that we hope will help you when planning your own migration journey.

1. Benchmark, benchmark, benchmark

It’s always a good idea to benchmark the current platform against the future platform to compare costs and performance. On-premises environments have a fixed capacity, while cloud platforms can scale to meet workload needs. Therefore, it’s essential to ensure that the current behavior of the key workload is clearly understood before the migration.

2. Focus on one thing at a time

We initially focused on reliability while remaining cost-neutral during the migration process, and then focused on cost optimization post-migration. Google teams were very helpful and instrumental in identifying cost optimization opportunities.

3. Be aware of alpha and beta products

Although there usually aren’t any guarantees of a final feature set when it comes to pre-released products, you can still get a sense of their stability and create a partnership if you have a specific use case. In our specific use case, Enhanced Flexibility Mode was in alpha stage in April 2019, beta in August 2020, and released in July 2021. Therefore, it was helpful to check in on the product offering and understand its level of stability so we could carry out risk analysis and decide when we felt comfortable adopting it.

4. Think about quotas

Our Dataproc clusters could support much higher node counts than was possible with our previous vendor. This meant we often had to increase IP space and change quotas, especially as we tried out new VM and disk configurations.

5. Preemptable and committed use discounts (CUDs)

CUDs make compute less expensive while preemptables make compute significantly less expensive. However, preemptibles don’t count against your CUD purchases, so make sure you understand the impact on your CUD utilization when you start to migrate to preemptables.

We hope these lessons will help you in your Data Cloud journey.

In-memory data stores are a fundamental infrastructure for building scalable, high-performance applications. Whether it is building a highly responsive ecommerce website, creating multiplayer games with thousands of users, or doing real-time analysis on data pipelines with millions of events, an in-memory store helps provide low latency and scale for millions of transactions. Redis is a popular in-memory data store for use cases like session stores, gaming leaderboards, stream analytics, API rate limiting, threat detection, and more. Another in-memory data store, open source Memcached, continues to be a very popular choice as a caching layer for databases and is used for its speed and simplicity.

We’re announcing Memorystore for Memcached in beta, a fully managed, highly scalable service that’s compatible with the open source Memcached protocol. We launched Memorystore for Redis in 2018 to let you use the power of open source Redis easily without the burden of management. This announcement brings even more flexibility and choice for your caching layer. 

Highlights of Memorystore for Memcached

Memcached offers a simple but powerful in-memory key value store and is popular as a front-end cache for databases. Using Memcached as a front-end store not only provides an in-memory caching layer for faster query processing, but it can also help save costs by reducing the load on your back-end databases.

Using Memorystore for Memcached provides several important benefits:

• Memorystore for Memcached is fully open source protocol compatible. If you are migrating applications using self-deployed Memcached or other cloud providers, you can simply migrate your application with zero code changes.
• Memorystore for Memcached is fully managed. All the common tasks that you spend time on, like deployment, scaling, managing node configuration on the client, setting up monitoring, and patching, are all taken care of. You can focus on building your applications.
• Right-sizing a cache is a common challenge with distributed caches. The scaling feature of Memorystore for Memcached, along with detailed open source Memcached monitoring metrics, allows you to scale your instance up and down easily to optimize for your cache-hit ratio and price. With Memorystore for Memcached, you can scale your cluster up to 5 TB per instance.
• Auto-discovery protocol lets clients adapt to changes programmatically, making it easy to deal with changes to the number of nodes during scaling. This drastically reduces manageability overhead and code complexity.
• You can monitor your Memorystore for Memcached instances with built-in dashboards in the Cloud Console and rich metrics in Cloud Monitoring.

Memorystore for Memcached can be accessed from applications running on Compute Engine, Google Kubernetes Engine (GKE), App Engine Flex, App Engine Standard, and Cloud Functions.

The beta launch is available in major regions across the U.S., Asia, and Europe, and will be available globally soon.

Getting started with Memorystore for Memcached

To get started with Memorystore for Memcached, check out the quick start guide. Sign up for a $300 credit to try Memorystore and the rest of Google Cloud. You can start with the smallest instance and when you’re ready, you can easily scale up to serve performance-intensive applications. Enjoy your exploration of Google Cloud and Memorystore for Memcached.

When it comes to learning how to implement some technology, we all have our own version of what I call the “tab game”—that is, your setup for all the tabs and windows you need open at once. You may have several monitors so you can see documentation, your IDE, and terminal windows at the same time. You may have several guides and references open at once in one window to get all the information you need.

Personally, I like to work just from my laptop because I like to move around and work from various comfy spots. I think my tab game would probably enrage most devs because it involves a lot of swiping back and forth between windows *and* toggling tabs. It’s not pretty. That is, it wasn’t pretty until I discovered tutorials in the Google Cloud Console!

Jen really didn’t know about tutorials in the Google Cloud Console?

Yes, I honestly didn’t know about them! I’m sharing about it because if I can work for Google and not know, then I can’t be the only one, and it would be a shame to miss out on this because it’s a brilliant idea. Also I wrote some pretty sweet tutorials for the console, but I swear that the main reason I’m telling you is because it’s a cool thing!

There are several reasons that these tutorials are great:

• You can view the instructions and the console at the same time. No more playing the tab game!
• The tutorials include links and highlights, making it easy to find the screens and buttons you’re looking for
• You can run code from Cloud Shell, so you don’t need a separate window for an IDE
• You can use the demo data provided to try things out, or you can apply the steps to your existing projects using data that suits your app’s needs

Firestore tutorials

I’m developing a series of tutorials in the Google Cloud Console designed to take you through everything you need to know about Firestore–from manually adding data in the Google Cloud Console to triggering Cloud Functions to make changes for you. Below are links and summaries for the currently available tutorials. Check back regularly to find the latest additions as they’re released!

Add Data to Firestore

• Enable Firestore on a project
• Learn about the Firestore data model
• Add a collection of documents
• Add fields to a document
• Delete documents and collections

Updating Data in Firestore using Node.js or using Python

• Add a collection of documents
• Explore available data types
• Replace the data of document
• Replace fields in a document
• Handle special cases: incrementing, timestamps, and arrays

Reading Data from Firestore using Node.js or using Python

• Add a collection of documents
• Explore available data types
• Read a collection
• Read a single document
• Order documents
• Query documents

Transactions in Firestore using Node.js

• Add a collection of documents
• Update data without a transaction to observe issue
• Complete a transaction
• Complete a batched write

Batched Writes in Firestore using Node.js or using Python

• Use Cloud Shell and Cloud Shell Editor to write a Node.js or Python app
• Complete a batched write

Firestore triggers for Cloud Functions

• Initialize Cloud Functions using the Firebase CLI
• Write a Cloud Function triggered by a new document write to Firestore

Offline Data in Firestore

• Add data to Firestore in the Cloud console Firestore dashboard
• Create a web app that uses Firestore using the Firebase SDK
• Deploy Firestore security rules that enable access to the required data
• Enable data persistence in the web app
• Observe app behavior with and without network connection

Chime in

Is there a particular action or concept in Firestore that you’d like to see a tutorial for? Is there another Google Cloud product that you want to learn more about? Tweet @ThatJenPerson and you may just see your suggestion come to life in the Google Cloud Console!