Not long ago, building AI into recommendation engines was a daunting, expensive task that could take years to get off the ground. But as Bazaarvoice has shown, with the help of cloud services, the time from AI investment to business outcomes is shorter than ever. 

Bazaarvoice is the leading provider of product reviews and user-generated content (UGC) solutions that help brands and retailers understand and better serve customers. Its 2019 acquisition of Influenster.com, a community of consumer reviewers 6.5 million strong, expanded the Bazaarvoice portfolio with a platform where consumers can share their candid opinions — and share they have, over 54 million times. 

After the acquisition, Bazaarvoice expanded the site’s product diversity by 53%, to more than 5.4 million unique products. To keep user engagement high, Influenster must be seen as both a source of trusted, transparent reviews and a place for customers to discover useful, relevant products for the first time. By introducing shoppers to new products Influenster not only provides value to customers but also helps brands collect consumer insights. 

Influenster started out as a place where people gathered to share their honest thoughts on beauty products but quickly expanded to nearly every category, from Art to Wearables. Because of the much smaller scope, the site started and flourished under a rules-based recommendation engine. However, as Influenster expanded its scope under Bazaarvoice, a more robust recommendation system became necessary. In its earliest days, Influenster was successful because of the human perspective it offered: For every product there was a litany of reviews and images that made users feel as if they were getting an endorsement on a product from a friend. 

The Bazaarvoice engineering team asked themselves how they could keep that same feeling of personalization with an ever-growing catalog of items and categories. They needed recommendations that could scale with the site, rather than requiring more rules be constructed each time a new product category was introduced. They also needed to ensure the Influenster experience would remain performant even towards unknown members.

Bazaarvoice tested out several recommendation engines, benchmarking each against their current rules-based system. In the end they decided on Google Cloud’s Recommendations AI because of its transparent billing, ease of integration and setup, and naturally, its proven results.

Transparent Billing

“Part of what the engineers loved was they knew exactly what it was going to cost as it scaled” says Nick Shiftan, SVP, Content Acquisition Services Product Unit for Influenster. The goal was to build once and innovate rather than leave a wake of technical debt only to be tackled when costs grew unexpectedly out of control. Google Cloud’s straightforward and pay-as-you-go billing allowed them to anticipate how costs would grow as user interactions did and plan accordingly.

Ease of integration

“I’m positively surprised how Google packed such a complex system in a very easy-to-use API” remarks Eralp Bayraktar, the Software Engineering team lead overseeing the project. Because the original team was made of just one full-time engineer the ease of integration became an even more critical feature. Not only does Recommendations AI pull from years of suggestion expertise in Google Search and YouTube, but in combination with Ad’s Merchant Center, it also creates a streamlined process for importing product metadata. From there, creating a model becomes a matter of picking the preferred recommendation type and then the business objective to optimize for. Once the model is created and the API integrated into the website, the code is already deployed at the global scale: There are no further architectural considerations to ensure recommendations are available to users worldwide. For Bazaarvoice, this meant going from ideation to production in one month.

Proven Results

“We have used it for product recommendations and off-loaded our DB-tiring business logic to Recommendations AI, which resulted in overall faster response times and much better recommendations as proven by our A/B tests,” Eralp continues.  

Bazaarvoice began by A/B testing Recommendations AI against their rules-based system. Early on in the experimental phase they noticed a clear and consistent 60% increase in the click-through rate over their original recommendation system. 

Even more impressive was the performance on Unknown Members. For every person that signs up for an account on Influenster.com there are many other visitors that come to the website and leave without fully registering. This is typically referred to as the “cold start” problem in the industry — how do you figure out what to recommend to those people without their history, behavior, or preferences? Recommendations AI gives you the option to input and train on unknown users, and by providing metadata on products, it can provide high-quality suggestions to registered members and first-time users alike. 

With a mind to the future, Eralp concludes his thoughts on Bazaarvoice’s experience: “It enables discovery by adding an adjustable percentage of cross-category products [for] healthier [traffic distribution] across all our catalog. We are investing in data science and having the Recommendations AI as the baseline is a good challenge for us to thrive.” 

To learn more about Recommendations AI and how it can help your organization thrive, check out our recently published 4 part guide which kicks off with an overview on “How to get better retail recommendations with Recommendations AI.” This series also covers data ingestion, modeling, as well as serving predictions & evaluating Recommendations AI. You can also easily get started with our Quickstart Guide.

May is Asian Pacific American Heritage Month —a time for us to come together to celebrate and remember the important people and history of Asian and Pacific Island heritage. This feature highlights three AAPI founders from the Google For Startups community.

Read on to learn how these three founders built their businesses, leverage Google tech, and suggestion they have for aspiring entrepreneurs.

CultivatePeople 

Founder: Lola Han

Description: CultivatePeople’s compensation software, Kamsa, provides global market pay rate data and helps companies make data-driven salary decisions so they can attract and retain their most valuable asset: employees. 

Why GCP: “CultivatePeople began using GCP when integrating SSO/SAML authentication after  our SaaS product became a high priority. We were able to exceed our clients’ expectations and increase their level of trust in our platform’s capabilities. We’re currently investigating additional machine learning products, such as Cloud AutoML, that will allow us to quickly deliver exciting features.” 

Note from the Founder: “I grew up with immigrant parents who value stability and are risk-averse. My parents discouraged me from starting my own company because they didn’t want to see me struggle financially or see my health suffer (due to stress). I felt strongly about what CultivatePeople could do, so I started the company as a sole founder in 2017 and watched it double in size year over year since. While the ones I love most may not have cheered me on initially, it was important for me to hang on to the encouraging words of former bosses, executives, and founders to keep me focused on my mission. 

My advice for other AAPI founders is to be a “silent assassin” and believe in the mission and values of your organization. Always remember to stop along the way and: 

 1) Enjoy the journey by celebrating wins and giving yourself credit;

2) Follow your intuition—it’s (almost) always right; 

3) Recognize and invest in your people regularly (ie. give increases more than once a year, if warranted);

4) Give regular words of affirmation to employees on even small achievements.”

Swit

Founder: Josh Lee and Max Lim

Description: Swit is a team collaboration platform that seamlessly combines team chat with task management by allowing teams to turn their conversations into trackable tasks and share tasks to chat with simple drag-and-drop functionality, ensuring everyone is on the same page and projects get done faster.

Why GCP: “Swit is a cross-category hybrid work tool for chat and tasks. This functionality requires more complicated and heavier architecture for performance. So, configuring and managing virtual machines was really challenging to scale up our systems, while handling occasional unexpected traffic surges and frequent updates. Eventually we divided our monolithic architecture into 35 microservices when we launched our official product. The migration to GKE took around one month, and it turned out to be well worth the effort—our systems became able to offer high scalability and enough resilience to keep its uptime no matter what happened. Now we’re operating 84 workloads and 252 microservices with high stability with remarkably low downtime – less than 0.00001%/year.”

Note from the Founder: “As an AAPI founder based in Silicon Valley, I feel proud of the work ethics and diligence fellow Korean American entrepreneurs and professionals have long demonstrated here. Especially with K-pop breaking into the mainstream, I feel even more proud of our culture that strives toward an absolute perfection molded through years of training and dedication. The mission-driven culture of Silicon Valley coupled with Google’s edging technology and creativity really helped us build a product that not only encompasses verticals but also transcends cultures. Swit is growing at an unprecedented rate, and we hope  to join the long list of successful AAPI entrepreneurs here. Swit’s close network with the AAPI community wouldn’t have been possible without Google support. We are grateful for this collaborative environment, and we hope to become the next-generation ambassador for collaboration after Google.” 

Check out more from Swit in their founder story.

WISY 

Founder: Min Chen

Description: Wisy develops technology to bring digital efficiency into the physical world, supporting consumer products businesses and making them thrive in the new economy. All of us have a bad experience when we can’t find the product we want to buy. That is a $1.9T problem in the consumer-packaged goods industry that Wisy is solving with AI and analytics to help manufacturers and retailers sell more by reducing out-of-stocks and waste at a global scale.

Why GCP: “GCP has an intuitive, easy to use interface, was lower cost, and offered preemptible instances with flexible compute options. Some of the reasons why Wisy decided to use GCP include instance and payment configurability, privacy and traffic security, cost-efficiency, and Machine Learning.

Wisy has been able to advance quickly with product development, as well as collaborate better and iterate faster in the creation of our AI models, while reducing costs by 40%. At Wisy, we are solving a problem that affects everyone who shops at a store.“

Note from the Founder: “Two years ago, I moved to San Francisco to expand my second startup, Wisy. This is when I learned that my name ‘Min’ stands for ‘minority.’ I was born in China, raised in a Black community in Panama, received scholarships to attend both Carnegie Mellon and UC Berkeley. I worked for 20 years in several countries, but I have never felt so discriminated against due to my race, ethnicity, gender and age than during my time in Silicon Valley. However, this is also the place I learned that my diverse life experience is my competitive advantage. My background enables me to recruit and relate to people in different countries, create scalable and flexible products for multinational customers, and run global operations efficiently.

My recommendation to AAPI founders is to find strength in their multicultural background. Don’t hide what makes you unique, do not limit yourselves, and do not let others limit you. You will lose your edge when trading authenticity for validation. Be proud and own your story.”

If you want to learn more about how Google Cloud can help your startup, visit our Startup Program application page here and sign up for our monthly startup newsletter to get a peek at our community activities, digital events, special offers, and more.To learn more about how you can help #StopAsianHate during Asian Pacific American Heritage Month and beyond, visit their website here.

When the world was forced to go primarily online, state governments also faced the reality of needing to provide community services without the health risk of meeting in person. Old systems that relied on interpersonal contact could not keep up. An unprecedented number of displaced workers swamped every unemployment system. The capacity challenges weren’t limited to state labor departments either. Everything from birth certificates and marriage licenses to apostilles and court system services that could usually be handled by a simple walk-in had to be scheduled in advance. Both internal and external communication suffered. 

To meet these challenges, many organizations turned to new technology solutions and innovative approaches.

How VAST helped Arizona get back to work

The State of Arizona had tens of thousands of constituents who relied on pandemic unemployment insurance and would also need tools to reenter the workforce.Tim Tucker, Deputy Administrator of the Workforce Development Administration for the Arizona Department of Economic Security, started preparing in late 2020. He collaborated with Google Cloud and SADA to introduce the Virtual Appointment Scheduling Tool (VAST) to State of Arizona staff members. Using VAST reduced the excessive workload taken on by the Workforce Development Administration as they got Arizona back to work. VAST lets constituents book an appointment, upload documents and forms, and conduct career counseling virtually. This helped constituents move through the system faster so they could successfully reenter the workforce.

That preparation paid off. As of September 2021, Arizona had recovered the majority of the jobs lost during the pandemic. It has also seen one of the smallest percent change in employment compared with pre-pandemic numbers. Even more impressive, Arizona is one of only five states where unemployment claims are now lower than pre-pandemic numbers. Using VAST helped them get people back to work faster and has become a permanent part of their unemployment program.

Bringing streamlined services to the community

To fully realize a solution to the challenges faced by our public sector customers, we focused on three key areas in which we knew we needed VAST to excel:

• Efficient staff allocation
• Streamlined internal meetings
• Confident constituent interactions

We also knew our customers needed to get VAST online fast, and it needed to work with existing infrastructure without requiring a total overhaul. These areas informed the design of VAST’s features and have allowed us to meet the challenges faced by agencies such as the Arizona Department of Economic Security.

Virtual Agent support and integrations

VAST gives constituents 24×7 virtual agent support powered by  Google Cloud’s contact center AI virtual agents. Virtual agents are custom programmed to fit the specific needs of each agency and community they serve. It’s easy to add new options and information whenever an update is needed. Virtual agents can be designed to understand the user’s intent and serve up relevant content for a smooth user experience on both ends of the system. Virtual agents run at scale and offer multi-language support, ensuring they can serve everyone in the community. By pairing these with VAST, constituents can experience seamless self-service. 

6 week deployment time

Most of our public sector clients needed a solution yesterday. VAST can be deployed rapidly, taking about six weeks from start to finish, which includes everything–even staff training time.

 Integration with Google Workspace and Chrome

VAST securely integrates with other Google solutions, such as Google Workspace and Chromebooks. We work to ensure VAST is fully functional within your existing systems.

Collaboration and support

SADA collaborates with each organization to ensure that the design, development, and functionality of VAST align with their needs. SADA specializes in helping public sector customers migrate to Google Cloud. 

Analytics

Application administrators have access to analytic data gathered by VAST and options to customize and add additional datasets.This data helps organizations find blind spots in coverage, fix service bottlenecks, and better organize internal resources. Leveraging this data gives organizations the power to make changes, resulting in everything from a smoother customer experience to cost savings.

To learn more about how Google Cloud has supported Arizona during the pandemic, check out this blog on how their vaccination distribution system leveraged Google Cloud to get the vaccine to more people. For more information on how VAST can streamline a customer experience.